theFae Shelf

Two release dates circled in red. Eight books that have been waiting patiently since last October.

Top Ten Tuesday

Top Ten Tuesday: Ten Books on My Fall 2026 To-Read List

Dani, EditorPublished 4 min read10 books

This post is part of Top Ten Tuesday, the weekly bookish linkup hosted by That Artsy Reader Girl at thatartsyreadergirl.com/top-ten-tuesday where book bloggers everywhere answer the same prompt each week. This week it is books on our fall 2026 to-read list, and for once I am not bending the prompt. Fall is my reading season. Every book with a foggy cover suddenly looks urgent.

I built this list in two passes: the romantasy release calendar for the two dates I have been waiting on all year, then the shelves of our fantasy romance library of 750+ titles for books that only make sense between September and December. Gothic houses, secret societies, witches, one very old vampire. If it would feel wrong in July, it qualified.

In this article
  1. Quick picks
  2. The Two Releases I Have Been Counting Down To
  3. Secret Societies, Haunted Libraries, and One Sea-Soaked Manor
  4. Witches, a Very Old Vampire, and a Cranky Professor
  5. FAQ
  6. Keep reading
Featured in this article

Quick picks

The whole list at a glance. Tap a title to jump to the full entry.

  1. 1Threshing DayRebecca Yarros4.5Spicy
  2. 2A Court of Splintered HarmonySarah J. Maas3.9Warm
  3. 3Two Twisted CrownsRachel GilligWarm
  4. 4Ninth HouseLeigh BardugoWarm
  5. 5The Atlas SixOlivie Blake3.6Warm
  6. 6Sorcery of ThornsMargaret Rogerson4.2Mild
  7. 7House of Salt and SorrowsErin A. Craig3.7Mild
  8. 8Kingdom of the WickedKerri Maniscalco3.9Warm
  9. 9A Dowry of BloodS.T. GibsonSpicy
  10. 10Emily Wilde's Map of the OtherlandsHeather FawcettMild

The Two Releases I Have Been Counting Down To

Threshing Day by Rebecca Yarros (September 29). The next Empyrean book is a collection of thirteen stories built around favorite characters and their dragons, with sixteen full color illustrations in the deluxe first edition. I have made peace with the format. Thirteen stories is not a novel, but it is Empyrean, and I will be reading it the day it lands.

A Court of Splintered Harmony by Sarah J. Maas (October 27). ACOTAR book six. Koschei, bound to a mountain lake for millennia, is stirring, and a Prythian still patching itself together after Hybern has to remember how to work as one. Our complete guide to A Court of Splintered Harmony has everything confirmed so far. The site has it at a 4 on our spice rating scale, which for Maas feels like a safe bet.

Two Twisted Crowns by Rachel Gillig. Not new, but new to me, and I refuse to read it in any month other than October. One Dark Window ended with Elspeth and the Nightmare tangled in one body and Ravyn left holding the pieces. The most autumn duology in the genre, and I have been saving the second half for a full year.

The surprise Empyrean release: thirteen interconnected stories built around a single legendary Threshing Day at Basgiath, the day cadets and dragons choose each other. Not book four, but a return to the world of Fourth Wing ahead of it, arriving between the quadrant's deadliest traditions and the fandom's loudest theories.

Book six of A Court of Thorns and Roses and the first movement of the Valkyrie Cycle. Weeks after House of Flame and Shadow, the Inner Circle is split over the Mask, Feyre and Rhysand have a newborn, and Koschei is finally stirring. Azriel narrates most of it.

Secret Societies, Haunted Libraries, and One Sea-Soaked Manor

Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo. Alex Stern, who can see ghosts, gets a free ride to Yale in exchange for policing the secret societies and the magic they run on. New Haven in autumn, tombs full of rituals, a missing mentor. Owned since 2019. This is the year.

The Atlas Six by Olivie Blake. Six young magicians are recruited to the Alexandrian Society, told that five will be initiated, and left to work out what happens to the sixth. It is the book everyone means when they say dark academia fantasy books, so I should read it before I keep recommending it.

Sorcery of Thorns by Margaret Rogerson. Elisabeth grew up in a Great Library where the grimoires whisper on their chains and turn into monsters if damaged. When one gets loose she ends up traveling with the sorcerer Nathaniel Thorn and his demon servant Silas, who everyone tells me is the best character in the book. Libraries, ink, a sensible cloak.

House of Salt and Sorrows by Erin A. Craig. A Twelve Dancing Princesses retelling set at Highmoor, a manor on a cliff over a cold sea, where four of Annaleigh's eleven sisters have already died. The rest sneak out to dance at night, and Annaleigh starts to suspect something is choosing them. It belongs on any list of gothic fantasy romance and has been on mine for three Octobers running.

Seven sisters live in a crumbling manor where one by one they fall mysteriously ill and die. The youngest, Annaleigh, begins to suspect a darker truth lurks beneath the tragedies. Uncovering the mystery may cost her everything, including her sanity.

Witches, a Very Old Vampire, and a Cranky Professor

Kingdom of the Wicked by Kerri Maniscalco. Emilia is a witch in a Sicilian restaurant family, right up until her twin Vittoria is murdered and she accidentally summons Wrath, one of the seven princes of Hell, to help find out why. Slow burn, food descriptions that should be a crime, Halloween week read. The follow ups lean darker, which is why the series sits on our dark romantasy books list.

A Dowry of Blood by S.T. Gibson. A novella written as one long letter from Constanta, Dracula's first bride, to the husband she has finally decided to stop obeying. Centuries pass, two more lovers join the household, and the book is really about what it takes to leave someone who made you. Short, lush, and a 3.5 for heat on our scale.

Emily Wilde's Map of the Otherlands by Heather Fawcett. The sequel to Encyclopaedia of Faeries sends Emily and Wendell from Cambridge to the Austrian Alps, hunting for a door into the faerie realm he was exiled from, while someone keeps trying to poison him. Footnotes, snow, and the least romantic person in academia slowly admitting she has feelings. My late November comfort read, chosen so the list does not end on a vampire.

That is my fall. If you came over from the linkup: hello, welcome, this site is what happens when a reading habit turns into a spreadsheet and then a website. Every book above has a page here with tropes and ratings, and the best romantasy books of all time list is the natural next stop. Tell me in the comments what is on your fall list, and whether ten books and one very busy October is a plan or a cry for help.

Emilia wants revenge on the witch who cursed her family, but to get it she must make a deal with the Prince of Demons himself. Together they must solve the mystery behind her family's curse, all while resisting a dangerous attraction that neither of them expected. It's dark Italian folklore meets enemies-to-lovers with real teeth.

Not Sure About Spice Levels?

Our spice guide explains exactly what each heat level means.

Read the Spice Guide

Frequently asked questions

How many books are on this list?

10 books. 6 are part of a series and 4 are standalones.

Which books on this list have little or no spice?

Sorcery of Thorns, House of Salt and Sorrows and Emily Wilde's Map of the Otherlands sit at 0 or 1 on our heat scale, so nothing explicit happens on the page. Spice Guide

Which book on this list has the highest Goodreads rating?

Threshing Day, with a 4.5 average from 294.8k ratings. Threshing Day

Keep Reading

Published September 22, 2026 by Dani.

Never miss a release day

Tap Notify me on any upcoming book and we email you once, on the day it comes out. No newsletter.

See upcoming releases