theFae Shelf
Alchemy of Secrets book cover

Alchemy of Secrets

Goodreads
3.8
pages
336
October
2025

Stephanie Garber's adult debut. Holland St. James meets a local legend called the Watch Man, who tells her she will die by midnight tomorrow unless she finds the Alchemical Heart. The hunt drags her through a hidden magical Los Angeles with a stranger who claims her sister sent him.

What is Alchemy of Secrets about?

Holland St. James is a graduate student in Los Angeles who has always suspected magic is real. She is taking Folklore 517, a class on local legends taught by a man everyone just calls the Professor, and one of those legends is the Watch Man. Find him, the story goes, and he will tell you when you are going to die.

Holland finds him. He tells her she will die at midnight tomorrow unless she locates an ancient object called the Alchemical Heart.

So begins roughly two days of running through a hidden magical Los Angeles, a city of old Hollywood glamour and secret bargains. Two men show up claiming they want to keep her alive. Gabriel Cabral says one thing. Adam Bishop says another. One of them tells her that her twin sister sent him. Holland has no way to check, and the clock keeps moving.

This is Stephanie Garber's first novel for adults, after Caraval and Once Upon a Broken Heart made her one of the biggest names in young adult fantasy. It is contemporary, fast, and broken up by short folklore interludes written in second person, which readers either enjoy or find jarring.

It was an instant New York Times bestseller, a Book of the Month pick and an Indie Next pick when it came out in October 2025. At 336 pages it is a quick read, and Sutton Foster narrates the audiobook.

Despite the adult label, there is no explicit content. It reads closer to her earlier books than the marketing suggests.

Read it if you want

Los Angeles. The Quill to Live gave it 8.5 out of 10, called it wonderfully weird and wacky, and said the city works as a character. Lynn's Books gave it four stars for the writing, the old-Hollywood worldbuilding and an ending they did not see coming. Everyone agrees it moves fast.

The reception overall is mixed, with a 3.84 Goodreads average from 75,000 ratings. The main complaints are a heroine who makes questionable decisions, relationships that feel shallow, a magic system that stays vague, and an ending that leaves questions open. Several reviewers say it feels like YA wearing an adult cover.

If you loved Caraval for the atmosphere and the feeling of not knowing who to trust, that is here. If you wanted her to change register for adults, she has not really.

Who it is for

Garber fans, and anyone who likes urban fantasy with a puzzle. It fits readers who want a mystery with romance on the side and no heat.

It is a 1 on our spice guide, fade to black at most. That makes it a safe pick for readers who prefer closed-door books, and it sits with the gentler end of our slow burn list.

Is Alchemy of Secrets a standalone? It is listed as book one of a series, and a second book is expected in 2027, though one reviewer felt the story was complete. Is there a love triangle? There are two love interests and a question of trust.

Content warnings

Show the content warnings

No official list found. The premise involves a death prediction and threats to the heroine's life.

Where it sits in the series

Listed as book one of the Alchemy of Secrets series, with an untitled second book expected in 2027. It is unconnected to Caraval or Once Upon a Broken Heart, so you can start here. A Universal Television adaptation has been reported as in development.

The Flatiron hardcover is 336 pages and the first printing was a deluxe limited edition. For readers deciding between this and her earlier work: Caraval is the more magical, Once Upon a Broken Heart is the more romantic, and this one is the most like a thriller. It is a good palate cleanser between longer fantasy series.

Alchemy of Secrets: FAQ

How spicy is Alchemy of Secrets?

Alchemy of Secrets is rated 1 out of 5 on our heat scale, which we call mild. The Spice Guide explains what each level means. Spice Guide

Is Alchemy of Secrets a standalone?

As far as our catalogue shows, yes. Alchemy of Secrets by Stephanie Garber is not part of a series, so you can start here.

What are the content warnings for Alchemy of Secrets?

No official list found. The premise involves a death prediction and threats to the heroine's life.

How long is Alchemy of Secrets?

Alchemy of Secrets is 336 pages. At an average pace that is roughly 7 hours of reading.

When was Alchemy of Secrets published?

Alchemy of Secrets was first published on October 7, 2025.

Is Alchemy of Secrets OK for teens?

Mostly, yes. It sits at 1 out of 5 for heat, so nothing explicit happens on the page. Check the content warnings for darker themes.

What should I read after Alchemy of Secrets?

If you liked it, try Soulstar, A Master of Djinn or Emily Wilde's Map of the Otherlands. They share the tropes that make Alchemy of Secrets work. Soulstar, A Master of Djinn, Emily Wilde's Map of the Otherlands

What readers say

Reviews appear after a quick check, usually within a day.